April 2008

Mongolia's China Syndrome

by Ola Wong

Posted April 20, 2008

As the world’s attention turns to Buddhist protests against Chinese rule and cultural domination in Tibet, another neighbor of China is protesting in a less peaceful manner. In Mongolia, anti-Chinese sentiment has taken a nasty turn. The ultra-nationalist group Blue Mongolia, for example, shaves the heads of women caught sleeping with Chinese men. “It is for their own good,” says Gansuren Damdinsuren, a Blue Mongolia board member.  “A small nation can only survive by keeping its blood pure.”

Mr. Gansuren claims Blue Mongolia has more than 2,000 members, not a small number in a nation of just 2.8 million. Even more alarming, Mr. Gansuren says his group is not adverse to violence. In an interview last summer, he told me his organization is training a fighting force for close combat, and that the group has access to weapons.

Indeed, Blue Mongolia has made public appeals to raise funds for nationalist “training courses.” Their aim is to reclaim the vanished Mongolian cultural heritage; "One Nation” is the group's rallying cry. When I met with Mr. Gansuren, Blue Mongolia’s leader, Khonkhereediin B. Enkhbat, was standing trial for the murder of his 17-year-old-daughter’s boyfriend. Sources say his motive was that the boy had been studying in China.

You don’t have to look hard to find Chinese victims of racism in the capital city of Ulan Bator. Rendo, a taxi driver tells of how he was stopped and beaten by a small mob the day before. The only reason was that he had taken two Chinese businessmen as customers. A Chinese restaurant owner, Ma, who runs a local eatery, testifies to how a mob vandalized his establishment and plundered the belongings of the Chinese customers. “The police don’t care,” he says. “It is all politically controlled. On TV they are allowed to whip-up hatred and talk about killing Chinese.”

Mongolia gained independence from the Chinese in 1921 after a revolution by the Mongolian People's Party and in 1924 adopted the name the Mongolian People's Republic. But it quickly became a satellite state of the new Soviet Union—the Buddhist monks were shot or sent to prison camps in Siberia; the monasteries were torn down and the clan system, which had dominated society, was crushed so efficiently that by the time people were allowed to use their family names again many had forgotten which name was theirs. The Mongolian script has been replaced by Cyrillic. With the Soviets came vodka and cultural dislocation. “Before communism there was no prostitution, no prisons or corruption; we want to revive the old Mongolia,” says Mr. Gansuren.

China is Mongolia’s largest trading partner and the driving force behind an impressive economic growth rate of over 8%. At the same time, Mongolians worry they are being ethnically and economically colonized by their gigantic neighbor. The fear is that they will become “Sino-fied”—the fate of their brethren in Inner Mongolia, which is now a Chinese province where the locals can hardly speak Mongolian.

There is also resentment against what is seen as bullying from the Chinese government. The Mongolians are Buddhists in the same strain as the Tibetans and the Dalai Lama has visited the country, which has caused anger in Beijing. Despite the fact that unemployment is rife, there are now 15,000 Chinese working legally in the country and several thousand more working illegally. Many employers prefer to hire Chinese, who cost less and are believed to work harder.

The Chinese government has not issued an official protest against Blue Mongolia or their activities. The organization could be dismissed as an “extremist bunch of good-for-nothings playing Nazi,” as Boldkhuyag Luvsanvandan, one of Mongolia’s leading industrialists, describes them. Still, the rise of a nationalist group founded on anti-Chinese sentiment does not bode well for the health of Mongolian society.

Mr. Wong is a Swedish correspondent based in Shanghai.

comments (50)
@ 2008-05-04 20:30:59
 很久很久以前,谎言和真实在河边洗澡,谎言先洗好,穿了真实的衣服      离开,真实却不肯穿谎言的衣服。后来在人们的眼里,只有穿着真实衣      服的谎言,却很难接受赤裸裸的真实。
pang jung @ 2008-05-01 23:32:50
Did you guys read that Chinese company was manufacturing Free Tibet flags in China? They gotta educate themselves. Learn languages! Read books! I think Chinese people who are demonstrating anti French or anti American they don't know what doing because they cannot read, spell in English what banner they holding! If China don't like freedom that's OK gotta live like in a prison having one child eating dog's meat, cat's meat, sparrow or grasss hoppers as well. Get that illegal Chinese out of any countries. Check their visa and kick their ass. ..........................................................................
Zhuan @ 2008-04-29 17:29:35
Anyone reading this article who thinks it's anti-Chinese, needs to go back to their ESL classes and study harder. The author is quite clearly saying this Mongolian nationalism is something sad and too be feared. And to all you justifying hatred against Chinese, Mongolians or Westerners because of the actions of a few of those nation's people, grow up!
ZhuJie @ 2008-04-28 15:13:29
I don't think this article is anti-Chinese anyway, if anything it makes Mongolia look bad. In fact, I'm more disturbed by the sentiments in the comments that show a lot of insecurity on the side of Chinese people. Ultra-nationalism and defensiveness on both sides will do no good for any of us.
zzj @ 2008-04-27 14:52:17
china has 56 peoples,we help and love each other.we have benefited a lot from the development of the motherland .i support the freedom of the news,but i oppose the mendacious report!
tang @ 2008-04-26 18:10:41
Many western people have been considered that Chinese is an evil nation,but I will tell you that history is the best materials to prove and predict what is true and what will be mostly happening.You know,own nation never break a war toward western nations and have been trading each other and the trends will last for a long time.It is not like Japan,German or France.The world war can tell us something really useful.Then we Chinese is an peace loving and friendly nation.Why so many people hate Chinese people?For interests?You know,our cooperation is benefiting both sides.What do you really want?Is Chinese people always live in a sad condition and at the same time,our hard work will contribute your happy future?If this is the western people's real thoughts,you are so selfish and ugly and have no rights to gain the fruits created by Chinese people.
simon @ 2008-04-25 15:39:32
The correspondent enlarged something rare information intentionally to instigate anti-Chinese feeling, this is the common method which has been done by CNN, BBC and other western anti-Chinese forces. Chinese never do harm to a country or a nation as what westerners had done! Liars will cheat goodness people to achieve their own goals.
Future of cHINA @ 2008-04-25 13:07:18
Well I am impressed. This article is based on so poor knowledge (almost not real ). Are there chinese correspondents work like this way? if there are !! .. hehehe .. poor china.
baagii @ 2008-04-25 01:16:41
This is a serious question. I think that the author raised an important question. I am a Mongolian. I must tell you that my feelings towards the Chinese in general negative. I think that most Mongolians (both in Mongolia and Inner Mongolia) have negative feelings towards the Chinese, distrust them, and dislike them for the following reasons: 1. Several thousand years old animosity towards each other - The Chinese must know very well that we - Mongolians forced the Chinese to build the Great Wall - 2000 years old and 4000 lies long defense structure. 2. Inner Mongolia is occupied and colonised by Chinese. Today, there are 20 million Han Chinese but 5 million Mongolians live in Inner Mongolia. 3. Thousands of illegal Chinese immigrants work in Mongolian construction and mining industries. They often violated the country's laws and rules. They use poisonous chemicals to extract minerals. So on. 4. The Chinese who come to Mongolia are often uneducated, poor, short, dark skinned, and dirty peasants. Therefore, Mongolians hate them. By the way, Mongolia - the nation of 2.4 million people, produces 15 percent of world's copper, 8 percent of gold, 30 percent of high quality cashemir and export them to all over the world. The Meng Nui and other Chinese companies are exploiting Inner Mongolian resources (milk, meat, livestock and minerals) . Eevebody knows that Chinese companies in Inner Mongolia are colonizers. That is han Chinese are hated by everybody - Mongolians, Tibetans, Japanes, French, Americans.
Moog @ 2008-04-24 15:49:35
Mr. Ola Wong wrote this article from his personal impression. This article is too single-sided and not for information, but for brain wash. As a mongolian man, i love chinese people and i know, there are many mongolians with the same meaning. I heard about those Nazi-guys and this is a very small group of young people, not so great. I hope, we must find a balance point between nationalism and globalism. It is very difficult to find this point in such a quickly developing time.
michael @ 2008-04-24 13:22:35
mongolians has long history links with chinese , Yuan dynasty was funded by Monglian hero Genghis khan. i think anti-chinese sentiment from some radical mongolians not reasonable and acceptable. china's economy can boost mongolia's , both can develop fast together.
a common chinese @ 2008-04-24 13:08:56
an irresponsible article,the author wrote this artile from his emotion not from the truth,maybe he don't know the truth,he hasnot the right to write the an article about this issue.Hope that western journalists can be responsible and honest.
shenhaiwei @ 2008-04-24 12:55:48
it is not the truth. as a news repoter, it is his responsibility to give the world a fair and true report. however, this jounerlist in this report caught a piece and boost it a whole. i hope he could be a little professional and have more professional morality
Michael @ 2008-04-24 10:51:11
Poor and stupid Mongolians, It is time for you to learn how to live with your stronger neighbor, otherwise, you are doomed. Period.
Bibo @ 2008-04-24 10:32:17
The article is correct. The anti-Chinese sentiment in Mongolia is becoming very abnormal. I am Mongolian and even I am disturbed by this dangerous wave of nazism in my country. Alas, often the media contribute vastly to bolster hate in Mongolians. Just watch TV vignettes or music videos on main channels. They are full of stereotypical villainous Chinese. Of course, corruption and mismanagement in Mongolia allows foreigners to abuse their stay in the country. It gives the impression to outsiders that they can do anything in Mongolia because the locals themselves neglect their own land. And the funny thing is that China did the least to harm Mongolia in the 20th century and yet it receives the most blames, while the country which tyrannized Mongolia for 70 years is still the best "brother" and "friend". That tells how stupid these Mongolian nazis are.
Wangchuk @ 2008-04-24 03:03:24
Mongolia got its independence from the Qing Dynasty in 1911 just as Tibet did. They recognized each other's independence in a treaty signed in 1913, a copy of which is publicly availabe in Ulan Bator. However, due to a conspiracy b/t Russia & the ROC, Mongolia later lost that independence in 1917 but regained in 1921 w/ Soviet help (Soviets later helped the CCP overthrow the Chinese Govt). Mongolia was independent in name only until about 1990 when the USSR collapsed. Tibet was independent from the fall of the Qing Empire to 1951 & only lost that independence due the PRC invasion. During this period, Tibet had its own separate govt, its own territory & population & conducted its own foreign affairs through its Foreign Affairs Bureau. The ROC never had any actual or legal authority over Tibet. China used to consider Mongolia part of China but now even the PRC recognized Mongolian independence. So if Mongolia can have independence from China, why not Tibet?
Victor @ 2008-04-24 00:49:47
我希望记者有一个公正的立场和客观的事实. 这篇文章的作者有些偏激. 是对所有中国人的一种偏见. 是对中国崛起的一种仇视. 无论如何, 中华民族都会屹立在世界民族之林. 并逐步确认领导地位!!!
al @ 2008-04-23 23:34:16
Here we can see a typical conflict between globalization(maybe not the normal one) and nation states. In this world no one want to be too much globalized, and no one wanna be too much nationalized. Then how to maintain the balance between the two may be a necessary testing point for the politicians. Let's say, under today's global context, leaning towards each side will cause pain to its people, so why not let all the ill-balanced politicians step down?
Jun Liu @ 2008-04-23 22:23:07
I am a Chinese,I don't know why you all like the articles that against China .Anti-Chinese?The Mongolian are really ridiculous.Truly speaking we don't care at all.So tell us Chinese how further you know about China.If you can't,please don't attack Chinese again and again,because it is really dangerous.Sometimes you should listen to our voice. anti-Chinese ,enjoying yourself ,boycott Beijing Olympic you wish ,free Tibet no way!!!!!!
Liu tianzhi @ 2008-04-23 22:01:24
One of my colleagu in from inner mongolia.at least they know mongolia character. but as far as i know almost all people in out mongolia don't know mongolia character. shame on you!!!
wong @ 2008-04-23 21:02:02
completely wrong info
Richard @ 2008-04-23 20:54:14
some western media are quite racism. They always invoke such national or religious hatred and conflicts. They will suffer themselves at last. Chinese should not believe what they said and keep friendly with Mongolians.
GO China @ 2008-04-23 19:45:25
Go China! be more powerful take control of the world! slave all westerners and stupid nations like mongolia, they are all mobs! China will be rule the world with Africans and Indians and all once exploited nations now be the masters! thrill, hum?!
Ronald @ 2008-04-23 19:20:28
Does anyone notice that a so-called nationalist movement of Mongalia, has the slogan written in English. Where is slogan in their own language or do they have one. One must wonder the movement was financed by NED which is the front for CIA. Read some of the comment. How many real Mongalian read and write English and even bother to read FEER on line.
s1 @ 2008-04-23 17:05:27
weak and lazy nation always fear strong and industrous nation.
jutech @ 2008-04-23 15:27:20
History is always changing,the world is the same. Sooner or later,OuterMogolia will come back again.Who knows!
Khulan @ 2008-04-23 14:55:37
First of all please at least read one book about Mongolian history and do some research work on the people that you interviewing okey !
Tsoomoo @ 2008-04-23 13:03:21
I haven't visited this site before, but it seems like just whoever can post their thought, first thing is that any country has this sort of anti groups which is very small. we have to know and keep in our mind that chinese are doing nusty and robber things in Mongolia, it 's far more harmful than this few anti chinese Mongolians, But also there a number of Chinese that doing things under law and respecting Mongolians, Only problem is number, ratio is respectively (good:bad) 1:1000. Anyway this article doesn't worth much beside the correspondent tried to tell about some true histories. Generally it appears like an article of one of 100 yellow papers of Mongolia.
Mongolian @ 2008-04-23 12:16:25
China has a long reputation of carrying out dirty little politics and no one talk about it. This article completely showed only 1 side of the story. There was a several murders, rape victims, and all other crimes that illegal Chinese did in the past and I think Mongolian people being very patient about it. Do I think Blue Mongolia is right? No, but they have a reason to be like that. So don't just try to take one side of the story and make any kind of judgment. I don't think we, Mongolians, are better than any other people on this earth, but we do have a right to protect our self and maintain our heritage.
Ari @ 2008-04-23 11:24:57
China produces useless people, and they spread all over the world in order to produce mess. Chinese government doing it on purpose, they should be shame on their policy towards their population handling. Their action in the World is just a rude!!!... They try to keep Tibet even they can not handle their own population. They send their useless people to the all around the world, and they call it “OUTSOURCING”, they send their mess called “FOOD”. All world saw the case that they were producing such a “HEALTHY FOOD=MESS” in their “HEALTHY WORKING PLACE= DIRTY PLACE”. Japan TV did show FISH imported from China. Perhaps they explain it as a taking part of the globalization. Mongolia should do something towards their (Chinese) crime in their country.
MGL @ 2008-04-23 10:21:20
It's not valid source. All of wrong.......... i hope you will be more professional next time. You don't know about MONGOLIAN history. Try to read about Mongolian history. It's wonderful....
tim @ 2008-04-23 09:13:45
these mongolians are really stupid. Anti-china brings nothing except poverty to them. Look at the situation in inner mongolia, which is quite different from that in Mongolia. There are two giants enterprises based in Inner Mongolia. One is Mengniu Dairy (2319.HK) and the other is Littel Sheep. Mengniu Dairy is quite successful in China. Little Sheep is seeking IPO. But what about Mongolia? They want to fight with China?with Chinese? Then they are doomed. Poor and stupid people.
Chang Zheng @ 2008-04-23 08:56:07
Your independent days are numbered... We'll come back and show you who's the real boss And yeah, we'll teach you how to properly write and speak in Chinese, too
T @ 2008-04-23 07:14:14
what? mongolia got its independence FROM china in 1921??? dude, who told you this?.. Till 1921, both Mongolia and china were under the rule of Manjuria for over 200 years. But its not something 'amazing' though, since chinese always claim everything was chinese. Even when Khublai /Mongolian King/ slaved china, they call that was Yuan Dynasty... lol a chinese dynasty where chinese were treated no better than dogs... It is a shit, comes from 2 shits - {china & romania}
sim @ 2008-04-23 06:19:36
Bull****!
Ricardo @ 2008-04-23 06:18:14
A Swedish "correspondent" based in Shanghai writing with "authority" about a "phenomenon" in Mongolia that can hardly be found outside a few isolated cases. I really don't care strongly about anti-Chinese sentiment in Mongolia one way or the other but I do expect much better quality from FEER... this is dubious at best.
tom @ 2008-04-23 00:41:15
Face it: China is Mongolia's biggest trading partner. Without them, you would be even poorer than you are. Try begging Russia to be your big brother again.
Baldan @ 2008-04-22 23:46:36
I do understand and respect freedom of info but you are off the chart. You are half Chinese and Gypsy. So go **** yourself
Enkhzul @ 2008-04-22 23:36:12
You can not emphasize on that symbol as neo-nazi. Even though it was german NAZI's symbol, it has been meant differently in our own Mongolian history, thus better not to write like it is a fact that the Blue Mongolia follows NAZI vision... Moreover, completely wrong things have been mentioned above. We are not here to criticize you but still we can not be quiet as it is talking about our country's present and the past... Please stop writing like chinese as you were there abused by mongolians... hope you are journalist.Good luck.
ola tang tong ping pong @ 2008-04-22 23:21:40
FIRST -You have to read MONGOLIAN HISTORY THEN YOU WRITE!!!!!!!! Ola Wong Ola Wong Ola Wong Ola Wong
Jim @ 2008-04-22 22:04:26
China is South Mongolia. Since the 11th Century, China has been ruled by either Mongolia or the Manchus. Only since 1949 have the Han people moved North to take beijing and wipe out the Manchu country.
sara @ 2008-04-22 18:01:58
FIRST -You have to read MONGOLIAN HISTORY THEN YOU WRITE!!!!!!!!
Administrator @ 2008-04-22 17:50:08
enigma, Tommy,


The date 1931 is incorrect, the author was referring to the 1921 revolution by the MPP, who, with the help of the Soviet Army, established the Mongolian People's Revolutionary Government in July of 1921. In 1924 the country took the name the Mongolian People's Republic. The article has been corrected, thank you for your vigilance.


Of course the issue of Mongolian independence is not as simple as this. The following passage from Xiaoyuan Liu's new history of Mongolia from 1911-1950, Reins of Liberation, might help to clarify: "In current scholarly references to Outer Mongolia's status between 1921 and 1945, it is common to point out the divergence between China's de jure sovereignty and Mongolia's de facto separation. Yet the latter's de facto separation can be easily interpreted as Russia's actual hegemony."
balt @ 2008-04-22 17:42:26
that symbol not NEO NAZI that is the Great Mongolian symbol "KHAS"
balt @ 2008-04-22 17:40:08
Wong is china right he is the chinese correspondent. okay everything`s definite. it`s the conspiracy china between Wong by the the way that symbol not NEO NAZI that is the Traditional Great Mongolian symbol
balt @ 2008-04-22 17:40:05
Wong is china right he is the chinese correspondent. okay everything`s definite. it`s the conspiracy china between Wong by the the way that symbol not NEO NAZI that is the Traditional Great Mongolian symbol
enigma @ 2008-04-22 15:02:28
The correspondent has no enough knowledge about what she writes. You are correspondent, so you have to write true. You don't have right to provide false information to people. You writes " Mongolia was liberated from the Chinese in 1931". It's not definitely!!! Mongolia has never been under chinese rule. Mongolia was under Manchuria's rule until 1921 year, and declared its Independence in 1924 year. U have to improve your knowledge. Don,t write what you don,t know well!!! so shame, you are a correspondent!!!
bad @ 2008-04-22 13:35:21
wrong information!
Temka @ 2008-04-22 13:25:12
Hey, Dont write such a things based on rumors. even it is true in same way, rumor changed when it is sperating. Mr.Wong, be responsible.
Tommy @ 2008-04-22 10:16:49
You cannot call this racism as both nations are the same race. Actually there have been many cases of chinese workers violated laws and harassed people, especially women in Mongolia, so that anti-china sentiment is growing in Mongolia nowadays. Most of chinese in Mongolia do illegal business and harm the country, just like they have been doing it for centuries. Even the Government of China has been having a number of different policies to f*** up the prosperity of Mongolia. I personally do not support these nationalist groups, but we have to remember the Chinese greed and mischieve against Mongolia all the time. They might be smiling and wondering how to get us in deep s***.



by the way, your sources are not valid. that 1931 year is a mistake. nobody kills someone for studying in china. i hope you will be more professional next time
 
Name:
Email:

Comment:

If you have trouble reading the code, click on the code itself to generate a new random code. For security reasons, please type the code you see in the image on the left.

 

Essays

Rehabilitating America

America has been the most benign dominant power in world history.

SlimStats Ignoring Local User.